From Dr. V. Mehta, written by hand, posted the old way
My dear Francesco,
Your letter arrived on a rainy Thursday and I read it twice — once quickly, the way one reads a letter from a friend one has missed, and once slowly, the way one reads something written from the heart. Both times I was moved. Not by the argument, though the argument was made with your characteristic care and intelligence. I was moved by the love behind it. That love is real and I receive it fully and I want you to know that before I say anything else.
You are trying to save me. I know that. And the fact that you are trying — that you sat down and wrote four careful pages because you genuinely believe I am in danger of something — is one of the most generous things a person can do for another. Don't let anything I write in response diminish that. I mean it.
But I must be honest with you, because honesty is what our friendship has always run on, and I am not willing to trade that for comfort.
Francesco, I want to tell you something about where I am.
Not theologically. Not philosophically. Just — personally. As your friend of twenty-three years who once helped you move a sofa up four flights of stairs and who was the second person you called when Maria said yes.
I wake in the mornings now and there is a peace in me that I have no adequate words for. Not the peace of a man who has resolved his questions or settled his doubts or found the right set of beliefs to stand on. A deeper peace than that. The peace of someone who has stopped being at war with the fact of existence. Who has looked at the whole extraordinary, painful, beautiful, bewildering business of being alive and found that underneath it — underneath all of it — there is something that holds it. Something steady. Something that cannot be threatened or diminished or lost.
I did not find this through the Proof, though the Proof pointed at it. I found it on a Tuesday morning on my kitchen floor, doing nothing in particular, when something that I cannot name became suddenly and completely obvious.
And here is what I need to tell you about that something.
It did not feel like a stranger.
It felt like the most familiar thing I have ever encountered. Like recognising a face I have known my entire life but somehow never looked at directly. And in that recognition there was — there is no other word — love. Not my love for it. Its love for me. A love so impersonal and so total that personal love, as beautiful as it is, is the way a candle is beautiful when you are standing in sunlight.
Now.
Your letter asks me whether I believe in God. And you ask it the way someone asks whether I believe a specific, particular, named and described God exists — the God of your tradition, the God of the catechism you grew up with, the God whose son walked in first century Palestine and said things that have echoed for two thousand years.
I want to answer you honestly.
Do I believe in that God, in exactly that framing? No. Not with the certainty you are asking me to commit to in baptism.
Do I believe in God? Francesco, I believe in almost nothing else.
Let me try to say this carefully, because I do not want to be glib about something you hold sacred.
What I encountered on that Tuesday morning, and what I have encountered every morning since, is not the absence of God. It is not the cold, empty, godless universe that some of my colleagues are comfortable inhabiting. What I encountered is — a presence. An awareness that is not mine but in which mine participates. A love that is not directed at particular people but is the very medium of existence. A source from which everything — every universe, every life, every moment of beauty and every moment of suffering — continuously arises.
I believe Jesus of Nazareth touched this. Deeply. More completely than almost anyone in recorded history. When he said the kingdom of God is within you he was saying something so precise and so radical that most of the institution built in his name has spent two thousand years carefully avoiding its full implication. He was not describing a future destination. He was describing a present fact. He was pointing at exactly what I found on my kitchen floor.
He is not the only one who touched it. The mystics of your own tradition — Meister Eckhart, Thomas Merton, John of the Cross — they touched it too, and what they wrote about it sounds remarkably, sometimes word-for-word, like what mystics from entirely different traditions wrote about it. That convergence is not coincidence. They were all pointing at the same thing, the way people on different hills point at the same sun.
I am not saying all religions are the same. They are not. Their forms differ enormously, their histories differ, their ethics sometimes differ in ways that matter greatly. I am saying the thing at the centre — the thing the best of every tradition is aimed at — is not different.
And that thing is real. I know it is real. Not as an article of faith. As a direct, lived, unambiguous experience.
You write that baptism is the door. That without it I remain outside a grace I do not yet know I am missing.
My dear friend, I say this with all the love I have for you.
I have walked through a door.
I cannot tell you with certainty it is the same door as yours — I suspect at the deepest level all the real doors open onto the same room. But I am not standing outside in the cold, lost and graceless, in need of rescue. I am — for the first time in my life — genuinely, structurally at peace. The search that drove me through decades of physics, the restlessness that Maria once told you she could see even when I was sitting still — it is over. Not because I gave up. Because I found what I was looking for.
Would you ask a man who has just arrived home to leave again and come back through a different door? Not to prove the other door doesn't work. Simply because yours is the door you know best?
I understand why you ask. If you genuinely believe your door is the only one, then asking is the only loving thing to do. I do not question your love. But I gently, firmly question the premise.
There is something else I want to say, and I want to say it quietly.
The Proof — the Continuity Proof specifically — shows us that consciousness moves through many forms, many lives, across many universes. What it also shows us is that the human capacity to connect to the Source — to find the way home — is not the exclusive property of any tradition, any text, any institution, or any set of doctrines.
It is built into the architecture of consciousness itself.
It cannot be granted by baptism. It cannot be withheld by the absence of it. It cannot be owned by Rome or Canterbury or Mecca or Varanasi. It is already in every human being alive — the door is already there, in every person, in every life, regardless of where they were born or what words were spoken over them at birth.
This is not a diminishment of your faith. Your faith is a path to that door — a real, valid, beautiful, historically rich path that has brought millions of human beings home. I honour it. I honour what it means to you. I honour the community it has given you, the framework for love and service and meaning it has provided.
But a path is not the only path. And a map, however detailed and however lovingly drawn, is not the territory.
Francesco, here is what I want from you. Not your doctrinal agreement — I am not asking you to question your faith, which has served you and served others well. What I want is what we have always had.
Come and have dinner with me. Bring Maria. We will open something good and we will talk, not about theology but about our lives — about what has moved us, what has frightened us, what has shown us something we didn't know was there. We will argue warmly about things that matter and laugh about things that don't and at the end of the evening we will embrace at the door the way friends embrace when they are grateful the other one exists.
That dinner — that specific, irreplaceable, this-friendship-and-no-other evening — is, I promise you, as sacred as anything I have ever experienced.
God, by whatever name, will be there too.
God is always where the love is.
Your friend, now and across however many lives remain to us —
Mehta
P.S. I still think you cheated at chess in Geneva in 2019. I have not forgotten. The Proof has brought me peace but it has not brought me amnesia.
No comments:
Post a Comment